You do not currently have permission to view the full text for this document. Please sign in to an account with an active subscription or contact support.
The distinction between truth and lie constantly confronts the psycho-analyst who has to apply in a rough and ready practical way ideas that have been the centre of discussion over the centuries. The rough and ready application may be too crude to do the work required of it. The psycho-analyst seeks ideas sufficiently accurate and robust to survive the emotional storms they should illuminate.
To the problems of understanding I have said that the psycho-analyst can bring something that is unknown to the philosopher of science because the psycho-analyst has experience of the dynamics of misunderstanding; the psycho-analyst is concerned practically with a problem that the philosopher approaches theoretically. Investigations of understanding and misunderstanding impinge on problems associated with truth and untruth. The reality of the problem becomes apparent when the psycho-analyst must ask himself, can a liar be psycho-analysed?
The problem can be formulated in grid terms without moral overtones. Category 2 (reserved for formulations known by the initiator to be false but maintained as a barrier against statements that lead to a psychological upheaval) would seem provisionally to offer a home to the lie. Such a categorization supposes that an experience has been permitted to continue to a point where the patient thinks he knows his formulation to be untrue, but is it true that he maintains it because it would be disturbing to his development not to do so? The lie could be uttered because in the view of the liar it would be profitable to him or injurious to another: is it correct in such a case to say it would be true, and if true significant, that inability to profit himself or injure another would lead to his having a psychological upheaval?