You do not currently have permission to view the full text for this document. Please sign in to an account with an active subscription or contact support.
The aim of this paper is to analyse how psychoanalysis develops research to validate its knowledge. The actual state of art of research in psychoanalysis reveals that this question is an area of controversy (Steiner, 2000; Widlöcher, 2003). The two major tendencies – the European and the Anglo-American approaches – reveal opposite perspectives, the former proposes the adoption of a model of research closer to the metapsychological view of psychoanalysis defended by Freud which emphasises the interdependence between research and cure (Steiner, 2000), and the latter calls for the use of traditional standards of science, proposing the use of quantitative methods of exact science to test psychoanalytic knowledge. The European rebuttals in this debate have been restricted to demonstrating on a practical level the inadequacy and the impossibility of psychoanalysis meeting the traditional standards of science. Nevertheless, there is a need to introduce a new scientific discourse in this debate that should take into account the specificities of psychoanalytic knowledge. The main argument of this paper is that there is urgent claim for agreement on the definition of the scientific status of psychoanalysis that needs to take into account the specificities of its knowledge and be supported by internal criteria of validation.